Have you ever wondered why some cigars taste smooth and sweet, while others feel bold and spicy? Or why cigar lovers argue endlessly about the best tasting cigars in the world?
Keep reading — because by the end of this guide, you’ll not only understand what makes a cigar taste amazing, but you’ll also be able to choose one with confidence.
And yes… there’s one flavor secret most beginners never hear about — but we’ll get to that later.
Contents
- 1 What “Best Tasting Cigars” Really Means
- 2 Why Taste Matters More Than Strength
- 3 The Flavor Factors That Decide Everything
- 4 The Aging
- 5 The 10 Best Tasting Cigars
- 5.1 1. Arturo Fuente Hemingway Short Story
- 5.2 2. Oliva Serie G Maduro
- 5.3 3. Romeo y Julieta Reserva Real
- 5.4 4. Padron 2000 Maduro
- 5.5 5. Perdomo 10th Anniversary Champagne
- 5.6 6. Valera Lopez Cigars
- 5.7 7. CAO Flavors (Vanilla, Cherrybomb, Honey)
- 5.8 8. Macanudo Café
- 5.9 9. Drew Estate Undercrown Shade
- 5.10 10. Ashton Classic
- 6 How to Choose the Best Tasting Cigar for You
- 7 The Most Common Flavors in the Best Cigars
- 8 Why Beginners Often Prefer Mild & Sweet Cigars
What “Best Tasting Cigars” Really Means
When people search for best tasting cigars, they’re usually asking two things:
Which cigars taste good for beginners or casual smokers?
What flavors, aromas, and qualities make a cigar enjoyable?
Taste is personal — but there are clear patterns in blends, regions, and wrappers that most smokers love. This article breaks everything down so even a 10-year-old could understand it.
Why Taste Matters More Than Strength
A cigar doesn’t need to be strong to taste good. The best tasting cigars balance three things:
Flavor: Sweet, creamy, nutty, spicy, earthy, or chocolate-like.
Aroma: What you smell while smoking.
Smoothness: No harsh burn, no bitterness.
A cigar with amazing flavor but terrible smoothness isn’t considered “best tasting.”
The Flavor Factors That Decide Everything
Let’s look at the elements that shape the taste.
The Wrapper
This is the outer leaf — and it controls 70% of the flavor.
Common wrapper flavors:
Connecticut: Creamy, sweet, mild
Maduro: Chocolate, coffee, sweetness
Habano: Spicy, earthy, bold
The Filler
This is the tobacco inside the cigar. It brings balance and aroma.
Dominican fillers = smooth, soft, woody
Nicaraguan fillers = spicy, bold, rich
Honduran fillers = earthy, deep, strong
The Aging
Just like wine, older tobacco tastes better.
Aged cigars are smoother, sweeter, and more balanced.
How to Recognize the Best Quality Cigars
Even novices can learn to appreciate the craftsmanship behind best quality cigars. Consider three critical elements:
The Wrapper, Binder, and Filler
Wrapper: The leaf that encases the cigar; it should be smooth, slightly oily, and free of blemishes.
Binder: Holds the filler leaves together; often overlooked, but essential for burn consistency.
Filler: The heart of the cigar; carefully blended for flavor, aroma, and balance.
The 10 Best Tasting Cigars
Below is a curated list of cigars that almost every smoker agrees taste great.
I selected these based on flavor clarity, smoothness, and consistency — perfect for someone looking for the best tasting cigars without getting overwhelmed.
1. Arturo Fuente Hemingway Short Story
Flavor: Sweet wood, light spice, cream
Why It’s Loved: Very smooth, never harsh, perfect for beginners.
2. Oliva Serie G Maduro
Flavor: Dark chocolate, coffee, nutty sweetness
Why It’s Loved: Maduro richness without being too strong.
3. Romeo y Julieta Reserva Real
Flavor: Cream, nuts, soft fruit notes
Why It’s Loved: Easy to smoke, mild yet flavorful.
4. Padron 2000 Maduro
Flavor: Cocoa, espresso, soft spice
Why It’s Loved: Iconic taste and perfect balance.
5. Perdomo 10th Anniversary Champagne
Flavor: Sweet cream, toast, vanilla
Why It’s Loved: One of the smoothest cigars on Earth.
6. Valera Lopez Cigars
Flavor: Earth, nuts, spices, cocoa
Why It’s Loved: Award-winning flavor but still approachable.
7. CAO Flavors (Vanilla, Cherrybomb, Honey)
Flavor: Sweet, dessert-like
Why It’s Loved: Great starter cigars for people who want sweetness.
8. Macanudo Café
- Flavor: Soft wood, butter, light cream
- Why It’s Loved: Ultra-mild and super smooth.
9. Drew Estate Undercrown Shade
Flavor: Creamy, nutty, hints of sweetness
Why It’s Loved: Premium flavor with low strength.
10. Ashton Classic
- Flavor: Cream, cedar, butter
- Why It’s Loved: A refined, classic “best tasting” cigar for beginners and experts.
How to Choose the Best Tasting Cigar for You
Everyone’s taste is different. Here’s a simple guide:
If you want sweetness
→ Pick a Maduro (dark wrapper)
Examples: Padron Maduro, Oliva Serie G Maduro
If you want creaminess
→ Pick a Connecticut wrapper
Examples: Perdomo Champagne, Macanudo Café
If you want no harshness
Examples: Valera Lopez Cigars, Undercrown Shade
If you want no harshness
→ Choose cigars with aged tobacco
Examples: Arturo Fuente Hemingway, Ashton Classic
The Most Common Flavors in the Best Cigars
1. Sweet / Creamy
Tastes like vanilla, butter, or sugar.
Best for beginners.
2. Chocolate / Coffee
Comes from Maduro wrappers.
Best for dessert-like flavor lovers.
3. Spicy / Earthy
Comes from Nicaraguan tobacco.
For smokers who want energy and punch.
4. Woody / Nutty
Mild and classic.
Great for everyday smoking.
Why Beginners Often Prefer Mild & Sweet Cigars
Harshness turns beginners away.
When you smoke a cigar that’s too strong:
the throat burns
the flavor becomes bitter
you stop enjoying the experience
That’s why the most recommended best tasting cigars are usually mild-to-medium strength—but rich in flavor.
The Arturo Fuente Short Story and Macanudo Café are top choices because they are smooth, mild, and flavorful.
Maduro cigars like Oliva Serie G Maduro or Padron Maduro offer natural sweetness from the dark wrapper.
Yes. CAO Flavors are great starting points for people who want dessert-like taste and low strength.
Not always. Many $8–$12 cigars taste amazing thanks to good aging and quality wrappers.
Balance, smoothness, a clean burn, and defined flavors like cream, cocoa, wood, or sweetness.
Now you understand what makes a cigar taste good — the wrapper, the filler, the aging, and the flavors.
But nothing compares to actually trying one yourself.
If you want to experience the best tasting cigars in the United States — smooth, sweet, creamy, or bold — explore our curated selection crafted for both beginners and passionate cigar lovers.
Your next unforgettable smoke might be just one click away.
Valera López Cigar, founded in 2020 in Miami, takes pride in offering premium cigars of the highest quality and reliable delivery service both within and outside of Florida. Our mission is to provide a unique experience with every smoke, ensuring satisfaction and excellence in every detail.
